PDA

View Full Version : Delhi BRTS


jpatokal
06-02-08, 12:52 PM
Another failure in the making, this time in Delhi (http://www.hindustantimes.com/storypage/storypage.aspx?id=dc77fb31-f47e-47e6-b938-f26120d159be&MatchID1=4639&TeamID1=7&TeamID2=9&MatchType1=2&SeriesID1=1169&PrimaryID=4639&Headline=10+weeks+to+go+for+the+BRT+corridor)... although you could search-replace "Bangkok" into it and it would sound the same!
10 weeks to go for the BRT corridor

In about 10 weeks from now, the much-delayed and controversial Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) corridor on the Josip Broz Tito Marg will be thrown open, with buses plying in segregated corridors and other vehicles in the rest of the lanes. Will the system work and are the authorities ready for it? Hindustan Times did a reality check to find out.

The final contours of the BRT system (earlier known as the High Capacity Bus System) have started taking a final shape on the about six-kilometre-long JB Tito Marg. The corridor, under construction for more than a year, has been in news for all the wrong reasons and has been a traffic nightmare ever since its construction started: many accidents and some deaths have occurred. ...

On paper, the BRT plan seems smooth with buses running in their lanes and fast and slow moving vehicles separated to avoid friction. A walk down the road, however, reveals a very different picture.

Wherever the bus corridor is closed to traffic, the adjacent lanes remain choc-o-bloc with vehicles, proving the fears of the Delhi Traffic Police, which was against the corridor. A car that had broken down on the stretch near Chirag Dilli proved another fear to be true — it had resulted in a pile-up. Many cyclists have started using the cycle track already but the ride isn’t easy. “I don’t have to fear the cars and speeding Bluelines anymore. But motorcycle riders too use the track during jams as it is not hard to change on to our track,” said Baldhari, a gardener. Not just motorcycles, even cars and buses could be seen changing lanes easily by driving over the small dividers. Then there were pedestrians, who were crossing the road wherever they found a gap in the oncoming traffic. ...

A senior official of the Delhi Integrated Multimodal Transit System Limited (DIMTS), which is supervising the project, too said that the traffic police would have to take care of such issues. Though there are only about 10 weeks left for the corridor to open, the traffic police have no plans to manage the problems that could arise. “I have no idea about the BRT corridor and have nothing to say,” said Qamar Ahmed, Joint Commissioner of Police (Traffic). With the authorities passing the buck, it is not difficult to imagine the scene on JB Tito Marg on April 1.

:(

pong
07-02-08, 09:18 AM
well dear Mr. Patokal, did not that Delhi Metro complete all in time and within budget? I remember having read some interview with the general supervisor, which seemed that he is the man to get things done- in time and on budget.
About the buses Ive only read of a few 100 fatalities of people falling down from overcrowded speeding buses per month. Its not that bad in BKK -assuming this is not just another story from journalists.

jpatokal
07-02-08, 01:08 PM
E. Sreedharan (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._Sreedharan) is indeed The Man when it comes to metro construction, but he has absolutely nothing to do with the misguided BRT project and it shows.

In short, Indian traffic is so chaotic that it would require draconian enforcement to keep the BRT lanes clear, and the article already indicates that the dividers are low enough that it's easy to cross in and out of them -- a recipe for disaster. So it's likely that the congestion in the area will get worse and BRT buses will get caught up in the jam, leading to a lose-lose situation. :mad:

jpatokal
20-02-08, 12:08 PM
Back in Dilli for a few days, and I've had the distinct displeasure of commuting along the BRT corridor -- the traffic is horrible even with the lanes still open to the public. And unsurprisingly, a story in today's HT states that expansion plans have been halted and also opines that there are now plans to allow all vehicles to use the BRT lanes outside rush hour, entirely defeating the point...

A few articles of interest:

CM halts work on new bus corridors (http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Delhi/CM_halts_work_on_new_bus_corridors/articleshow/2793732.cms)

BRT corridor: Red light every half km (http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Delhi/BRT_corridor_Red_light_every_half_km/articleshow/2783874.cms)

jpatokal
28-04-08, 06:05 PM
The Delhi BRT is now open on trial basis, and predictably chaos ensued:

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Delhi/Corridor_of_chaos_No_Sunday_relief/articleshow/2989265.cms

...to such an extent that the whole project may be scrapped:

http://www.ibnlive.com/news/chaos-complaints-may-see-delhi-brt-being-scrapped/63908-3.html

Yappofloyd
29-04-08, 12:32 PM
Hey thanks for the update. All new BRT routes will have teething problems and there seems to be a few desing problems with this Dehli route. I'm sure that the same will occur here when the BRT opens. An interesting quotes in the second article;
“If you take any junction (on the stretch), the volume of traffic is so high, it is beyond the capacity levels. It just cannot be handled,” said traffic expert, P K Sarkar.

Sources in the traffic police say the project was conceived with traffic figures for 2003. Design flaws and not considering the road behavior of the Delhi driver added to the woes.

Government sources say that in an election year in the Capital, the Congress leadership is worried that anger over the bus project could have an adverse fallout.
So the traffic expert seems to be saying that the volume of traffic already exceeds the capacity of the road. So isn't that what the BRT should be there to promote....people switching from their cars to the BRT?

The decision makers (ie. pollies) need to have a bit of spine and bear the initial backlash from drivers dealing with change traffic patterns.

jpatokal
09-05-08, 01:53 PM
The Delhi govn't has decided to run the second stretch of BRTS in an entirely different way from the first (http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/Next-on-BRT-New-pilot-project-new-rules/306374/):
Desperately seeking answers for a smooth ride on the Bus Rapid Transit System (BRTS) in the Capital, the Delhi government has now decided to run a second pilot project between Moolchand and Delhi Gate. ...

The segregated bus lanes and stops that were in the centre of the road in the first stretch between Ambedkar Nagar and Moolchand will now be on the left side. Unlike in the first pilot project, bus lanes will not be separated by concrete barriers — instead, they will be defined by lines in yellow paint.
In Delhi, where lane discipline is notional at the best of times (I was once driven by a taxi into oncoming traffic on the wrong side of the road on an expressway! :eek: ), this is a recipe for an even worse mess... and other cities who had BRT plans are now running away as fast as they can:

Ahmedabad cancels BRT tenders. (http://www.thaindian.com/newsportal/business/ahmedabad-cancels-brts-tenders_10045071.html)

Hyderabad puts its BRT on the back burner. (http://www.siasat.com/english/index.php?option=content&task=view&id=264809&Itemid=79&cattitle=Hyderabad)

Mumbai adopts a "wait and watch" policy. (http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/BRTS-Plans-still-on-drawing-board-expect-snags-like-Delhi-say-experts/305040/)